Perpetual Innovation

Category: Apple

  • Apple Loses Patent Infringement Suit, Ordered to Pay $533 Million | Rolling Stone

    Apple Loses Patent Infringement Suit, Ordered to Pay $533 Million | Rolling Stone:

    It seems apropos that Rolling Stone would have a great report on the iTunes (Apple) law suit loss to the tune of 1/2 billion dollar$. The loss rules that Apple did infringe on the 6 patents related to the storing and accessing of songs, videos and games.

    In the suit that might well be called the the Apple vs. the Troll, the ruling was that Apple not only infringed, but willingly did so and consequently results in the terrible treble-damages penalty that makes patents such a powerful weapon.

    The other company is Smartflash. This is a non-practicing entity (NPE), that might unkindly be called a patent troll.

    Apple plans to appeal. Smartflash is aiming for the iPhone and iPad sales/profits because those devices actually play iTunes music that is subject to the infringing patents.

    Imagine how many billion paid downloads from iTunes it takes to make up a $0.5B to pay the fine.? WoW.

    This could get uglier and uglier.

    ‘via Blog this’

  • Google to sell Motorola to Lenovo for $2.91B – FierceWireless

    Google to sell Motorola to Lenovo for $2.91B – FierceWireless:

    This is a pretty good take on the strategic transaction that Google has entered into with Lenovo.

    The headlines will be very misleading related to the Motorola Wireless deal that Google just made for selling the handset division (hardware) to Lenovo. People will look at the almost $12.4B deal where Google bought some 17,000 and the Motorola wireless division that comes with it in May of 2012. and say that Google gooped up on this transaction. (Somewhat reminiscent of the Skype deals where Microsoft ended up with the technology at a small price compared to what eBay paid a few years earlier.)

    This is a very smart deal by Google. Google is apparently keeping all of the software patents. The licensing (cross-licensing) agreements will probably give Google freedom to do whatever they want in the space. It takes them out of the hardware business, which made handset makers nervous (as an unfair competition with the bundle of handsets with Android OS).

    When Google bought Motorola Mobility as a defensive maneuver. The problem is that Google’s “free” operating system and products tromp on thousands and thousands of patents (and copyrights). So they needed the patent portfolio to fight the patent war in computing and mobility. (Just as Microsoft needed the AOL patents.) Steve Jobs and Apple have been very irritated with Google giving away (their) technology; but it is a little more complicated to sue and make money from a product being sold for $0.00 per unit.

    Even though Google gives many of its products way for “free”, it does make quite a lot of money, primarily from advertising. About 70% of Google’s stock value is attributable to its advertising (about half PC and half mobile). Google now is at a market cap of $380B bringing it up quickly onto size of the two largest market cap companies in the world Apple ($450B) and ExxonMobil ($411B) as of Jan 30 2014.

    So now Google has the patent protection they had to have, and they have sold it too. Beautiful. Now they can move into the offensive position in the patent wars. This is a game of Risk, but with multiple dimensions like 3-level chess. There is what you see above the board, but what is below the board — where the patent portfolios live — is where the armies are being amassed.

    Make no doubt, small players will be crushed. Blackberry and maybe even Nokia will likely be completely isolated. Orphaned.

    This will give Samsung a little competition. Samsung dominates the cell phone market, especially among android phones. See add to Samsung Worries. Google can not afford to allow Samsung to get too big and too strong.

    From Googles perspective, this is a work of motion art. Beautiful.

    Other players, say Apple, may not appreciate the beauty of it so much.

    ‘via Blog this’

  • Apple, Samsung, Google and the smartphone patent wars – everything you need to know | Technology | theguardian.com

    Apple, Samsung, Google and the smartphone patent wars – everything you need to know | Technology | theguardian.com:

    This is an interesting overview of the many concepts associated with patents and patent strategies.

    Very nice overview.

    Of course you will also want to get the Patent Primer 2.0 at one of these fine book store locations near you:

    ‘via Blog this’

  • Apple-Samsung Case Muddies Future of Innovation – NYTimes.com

    Apple-Samsung Case Muddies Future of Innovation – NYTimes.com:

    Oh boy, this is gonna get ugly. Especially if you are in the habit of ripping off other companies technology.

    Samsung, just got smacked down hard. A $1B verdict is just the beginning. Apple will of course, try to get treble damages for “willful” infringement of Apple’s technology. But the $1B is only the beginning. On September 20, the hearing (resumes) related to an injunction of the sales of Samsung’s offending products.

    One would assume that the new Samsung line (Galaxy) does not infringe, but that too may soon become subject to tighter scrutiny.

    Faced with injunctions or licensing Apples technology, that is the issue that will be confronting players in the market, including Google.

    The war chests of patents are: Apple; Samsung (kinda); Google (now with Motorola wireless that they seem to have bought primarily for the patent portfolio); and Microsoft (now with a boat load — $1B worth actually — of patents from AOL).

    Who else is there. RIMM? Palm’s technology that went to HP is dwindling fast.

    Of course, Samsung is appealing. But it’s outlook is not, well, appealing. And this loss in the US, is going to seriously shape the face of the screen in there rest of the world.

    Samsung is down 7% in Asian trading on Monday Aug. 27, 2012. Expect Apple to open up big on Hurricane Isaac Monday.

    ‘via Blog this’

  • Apple, Samsung, Kodak, imitation… a little more… on the patent war.

    Apple, Samsung, Kodak, Imation: Intellectual Property – Businessweek:

    Here you go with a huge patent war. Smartphones, iPads and more.

    Apple has been trying to injoin Samsung from sales of Galaxy product line. No injunction yet, but Apple is winning so far in the USA. Kinda.

    This law suit will be telling.

    In the meanwhile the Apple-Samsung war is being fought across the globe. In Germany this week, Apple lost miserably and was ordered to make a public apology. That was belayed yesterday until appeals have been processed. See more about the apology and appeal here.

    The smartphone war chests are Apple, Samsung, Microsoft and Google. All those players in the market that don’t have to stand back and see the last gladiator(s) standing. It’s gonna be ugly for most/all of the other players?

    And whatever happened to all the great technology from Palm (HP)? I’m surprised the HP doesn’t sell or license it. Blackberry (RIMM)?

    Forget about the Olympics, the real contest is in the smartphone arena.

    ‘via Blog this’